We have confirmation that there will be a single graveyard cookie, that is determined by the individual Crumbl store, during the week of Halloween. There has been much debate and online chatter when it comes to themed cookie weeks at Crumbl. The initial Halloween cookie and dessert menu was so poorly received that corporate changed the menu. The 2025 Halloween menu is as follows:
- Reese’s Peanut Butter Candy Brownie (NCD)
- Pumpkin Cheesecake Cookie
- Dirt Cake Cookie
- Halloween Confetti Milkshake Cookie
- Cookie Dough Cookie
- French Toast Cookie
- Semi Sweet Chocolate Chunk Cookie
- Graveyard Cookie
The Cookie Dough Cookie and French Toast Cookie were added after Crumbl launched the Requests tab in the Crumbl app and these two cult classics were highly, highly upvoted. This Halloween menu is significantly better than the original that included Monster Cookie ft M&M’s Candies and the Secret Menu. Fortunately, the diehard fans got this menu changed and improved.