The upcharge price on Banana Pudding at Crumbl locations is $0.99 and the dessert has 840 calories.
One reddit reviewer stated there were no bananas in their banana pudding:
“No joke… there was not even one piece of banana in there…
I went to Ralph’s, cut up a banana and polished it off.
Pretty good but not anywhere near as good as Magnolia Bakery banana pudding, in my opinion. What do you guys think?”
Many reviews have come in and the main complaint is either the complete lack of bananas or the bananas being brown and old. This likely happens when stores make the banana pudding two days in advance and allows it to sit in the refrigerator. This is something Crumbl Corporate has eased on as prior to 2024 Crumbl required stores to never sell cookies that were made well in advance. It will be interesting to see if stores start to figure out how to make more fresh banana pudding without getting completely backed up and have to go into sold out mode.
The latest tester dessert at Crumbl is Banana Pudding. This Limited Time Offer (LTO) is sure to be very popular as very few fast few restaurant chains offer the American favorite of Banana Pudding. This dessert is described as “layers of banana-packed vanilla pudding and vanilla wafers, served in a cup.” He is a review from someone that purchased the tester Banana Pudding in Virginia, “It comes in a little cup and is cold/refrigerated. It was delicious! Super rich and filling. I’m a big banana pudding fan, I know not everyone is. I had like 4 bites as you can see and then had to put it back for later snacking. It was a $.99 up charge just like the strawberry shortcake making it unfortunately $5.99 which seems steep for this kind of thing, idk.”
The Banana Pudding LTO dessert will come in a small cup similar to the Berry Trifle Cake Cups.
As more taste reviews are available, we will publish them here. We will also update this page with the calories and price with the up charge.
- It comes in a little cup and is cold/refrigerated. It was delicious! Super rich and filling. I’m a big banana pudding fan, I know not everyone is. I had like 4 bites as you can see and then had to put it back for later snacking. It was a $.99 up charge just like the strawberry shortcake making it unfortunately $5.99 which seems steep for this kind of thing, idk.
- It’s nothing like magnolia bakery. Crumbl’s is super watery not pudding like at all. The flavor is there but it’s like eating banana, soft nilla wafers, and some whipped cream in milk.
@maxandsnax1 NEW Crumbl Test Item: Banana Pudding Review #crumblcookies #crumbl #crumblreview #bananapudding ♬ original sound – maxandsnax1
It will be interesting to see how the Crumbl Banana Pudding stacks up against the homemade banana pudding that is available at Smithfield’s Chicken and BBQ.
View this post on Instagram