The average rating for Banoffee Pie is 4.26 stars which is the 5th lowest rating of the six desserts/cookies the week of September 9-14, 2024. Some of the reviews are as follows:
- I loved it. It was really good. The cookie was soft but not underbaked. The flavor was rich. I wanted to eat the whole thing but didn’t. And it was still good the next day. The other commenter was right about eating it a little chilled. So good
- I tried it. It was good but definitely not a favorite for me.
- If you’re a fan on banana flavored things you’ll love it, it’s the same flavor level as a banana runt not nearly like banana taffy. If you’re not too fond of banana steer clear. 🤗
- I thought it was cloyingly sweet and the base was mealy. Mine might have just been an off batch though because usually I like everything and this cookie has gotten good reviews.
Banoffee Pie will have no upcharge price. The total calories are 640 with total fat being 32g and total sugars 60g. The nutrition facts for Banoffee Pie at Crumbl are below:
We have learned Banoffee Pie will be on the rotating menu at Crumbl Cookies locations nationwide during the week of September 9-14, 2024. For those that may not know, Banoffee is a combination of the words banana and toffee. The Banoffee Pie cookie at Crumbl will have actual bananas and not just banana flavoring. Note that it does not have toffee but the caramel acts as the toffee.
Crumbl has committed to bringing flavors you’ve never seen before to the menu. This campaign started in September of 2023 and will likely continue through the holidays and maybe even into 2023. The latest tester flavor is Banoffee Pie. A reddit user described it as
After years and years of never knowing what Banoffee Pie was (thanks Love Actually), I was so excited to see this flavor as a tester at my location. I audibly gasped.
The cookie base was lovely, but the star of the shoe was the banana. YUM. It was exactly what I wanted it to be. Basically a banana cream layer, with a. Toffee caramel layer under it. Covered with whipped cream.
I will definitely get this again! 4.8/5 (because no cookie is ever perfect…but this was close.)
Crumbl describes the cookie as “an infusion of banana caramel packed into a scrumptious cookie pie. A chilled buttery graham base piled with a layer of gooey caramel, a swirl of banana buttercream, fluffy whipped cream, and a sprinkle of dark chocolate shavings.
