Carrot Cake is on the menu for the week of Easter (March 25-30, 2024). At this point, we cannot confirm if it will be the new 2024 Carrot Cake which is much more of a double decker cake than a cookie. We could see the older version of Crumbl’s Carrot Cake. We have had no non-cookie offerings in March so it would make sense the Easter week Carrot Cake will be the double decker cake.
While Carrot Cake has been a cookie on the rotating menu in the past, we have never seen the new and improved Carrot Cake that is being tested in 2024. Crumbl employees have stated that a non cookie offering is coming in March and it could very well be the new Carrot Cake or the Iced Lemon Cake/Square. The 2024 version of the new Carrot Cake “cookie” is described as “two tiers of carrot cake mixed with warm spices, coconut, pineapple, and carrots, all layered with a light glaze and vanilla cream cheese frosting, then topped with chopped pecans.” When this goes on the rotating menu, we will update this page with taste reviews.
