UPDATE: In 2024, Crumbl Cookies will have Mallow Creme ft. Lucky Charms on the rotating menu for St. Patrick’s Day week.
Crumbl is switching up the recipe for the old “Lucky Charms cookie” for St Patrick’s Day in 2023. This year, the Mallow Creme Lucky Charms is going to have a Lucky Charms base rather than a sugar cookie base. It is likely the case that this base will include marshmallows. There will be a vanilla marshmallow cream cheese frosting and, of course, some Lucky Charms marshmallows on top of the cookie. This is sure to be one of the most popular cookies of the St Patrick’s Day cookie menu.
The old “Lucky Charms cookie” looks like this. Note that this is the cookie with a sugar cookie base and not the Lucky Charms marshmallow base:
