During the week of June 16-21, 2025 Crumbl Cookies will run their Peanut Butter Cup Skillet cookie for the first time. This cookie is described as “a peanut butter cookies topped with peanut butter cup-packed mousse, drizzled with melted milk chocolate and topped with more peanut butter cup chips”. The dessert is showing up in the Crumbl app as Dessert #1 6/15 the week prior to it being available.
This cookie will likely not have an upcharge price as most skillet cookies have been the same price as large desserts. We will update this page when we get both positive and negative taste reviews. If you love peanut butter and enjoy the taste of a “skillet style cookie” with a dollop of cream or ice cream on the top, you will likely love this dessert.
Many times, Crumbl customers wonder if the color of the mousse topping is off or discolored with skillet style cookies. Some customers report the mousse is white and basically looks like vanilla ice cream while others say the mousse looks yellow and not good to eat. It will be interesting to see if this is the case with the Peanut Butter Cup Skillet Cookie.
