UPDATE: Crumbl changed the name of this cookie to Chocolate Peanut Butter Puffs. In the last few weeks, they have dropped the brand name of cereal off the name of the cookie such as Cinnamon Crunch (not Cinnamon Toast Crunch) during the week of August 21-26, 2023.
During the week of August 28th through September 2nd, 2023 Crumbl will have Peanut Butter Milk ft. Reese’s Puffs on the weekly menu. There have been a few variations of this cookie but not Peanut Butter Milk ft. Reese’s. Most of the past Reese’s cookies did not have puffs nor the “milk” type of cream cheese frosting. The last time this type of cookie ran on the weekly menu it was cereal week. Note that 8/28-9/2, 2023 is not cereal week in 2023.
This is what the last iteration of the Reese’s Puffs cookie looked like:
Here is the social media video they posted in March of 2022:
It will be interesting to see how diehard Crumbl fans respond to the newest version of this cookie. In the past several months many Crumbl customers have complained that the cookie flavors are getting worse and Crumbl is cutting corners with their cookies. Hopefully that is not the case with the Peanut Butter Milk ft. Reese’s Puffs Crumbl cookie.