UPDATE: Peppermint Ice Cream will be on the main menu for Crumbl Cookies during the week of December 18th-23rd, 2023. If you want to get a Peppermint Ice Cream chilled cookie right before Christmas, do so before December 24th as Crumbl will be closed Christmas Eve, Christmas Day and the Day After Christmas in 2023.
In August 2023 Crumbl Tester Stores had Peppermint Ice Cream as a “testing flavor”. This cookie is described as “a chilled vanilla bean cookie with large chunks of peppermint pieces. Swirl with pink peppermint white chocolate frosting and ringed with crushed peppermint. Here is a review from a redditor:
4.75/5 – Hi folks! Crumbl throws the word “ice cream” a lot. I am telling you right now that this is the first one that actually tastes like it’s ice cream counterpart. This is a very nice cookie with a light peppermint flavor. The candy cane pieces are a major bonus here.
No cookie is perfect, hence the 4.75…but it’s close.
Favorite so far – Strawberry Limeade ft. Nerds
Least favorite so far – Cereal Milk sandwich ft. Fruity Pebbles
