While Crumbl Cookies locations have not been testing out a ton of new cookies, in May 2025, we could have a winner – Sea Salt Toffee Skillet Cookie. We know the sea salt toffee cookies are incredibly popular at Crumbl. We also know the skillet cookies do very well. When you combine the two, you could have a sold out cookie for an entire week. The Sea Salt Toffee Skillet Cookie is described as, “a gooey toffee cookie topped with fresh vanilla bean mousse and drizzles of milk chocolate and caramel, all finished with a crunch of more toffee pieces and some flakey sea salt.”
As soon as we get nutrition information such as total calories, fats and sugars, we will update this page. We will also be sure to update when this cookie will be on the rotating menu at all Crumbl Cookies locations throughout the United States and Canada.
