One of the latest non cookie desserts (NCD) that we will see on the Crumbl Cookies rotating menu is Peanut Butter Pretzel Brownie. For the first time ever, Crumbl will be running this speciality dessert during the week of August 11-16, 2025. The pretzel cookies have been very popular at Crumbl so it will make sense that this salty and sweet treat will be a hit. Here are a few reviews of the tester version of the peanut butter pretzel brownie at Crumbl:
- Pretty solid brownie tester, there’s like a layer of pretzel along the bottom. The pretzel comes through a decent amount at the beginning but overall I’d say the peanut butter is the more dominant of the two flavors. The crunch from the layer on the bottom is my only critique as I like a more uniform brownie texture, but all in all it’s a solid 7/10 (5 being average)
- She was CRHONCHY! The peanut butter whip on the top was pretty good but I didn’t like how crunchy the brownie was, it was a bit hard to eat and fell apart 🙁 conceptually she was a good idea.
This dessert is sure to have an upcharge of about +$1.49 and will likely have over 1000 calories similar to the S’mores Brownie.
